← All publications

Judging Thieves of Attention: Commentary on “Assessing Cognitive Distraction in the Automobile,” by Strayer, Turrill, Cooper, Coleman, Medeiros-Ward, and Biondi (2015)

Hancock, P. A., & Sawyer, B. D. (2015). Judging thieves of attention: Commentary on “Assessing cognitive distraction in the automobile,” by Strayer, Turrill, Cooper, Coleman, Medeiros-Ward, and Biondi (2015). Human Factors, 57(8), 1339-1342. https://doi.org/10.1177/0018720815578971

Abstract

The laudable effort by Strayer and his colleagues to derive a systematic method to assess forms of cognitive distraction in the automobile is beset by the problem of nonstationary in driver response capacity. At the level of the overall goal of driving, this problem conflates actual on-road behavior; characterized by underspecified task satisficing, with our own understandable, scientifically inspired aspiration for measuring deterministic performance optimization. Measures of response conceived under this latter imperative are, at best, only shadowy reflections of the actual phenomenological experience involved in real-world vehicle control. Whether we, as a research community, can resolve this issue remains uncertain. However, we believe we can mount a positive attack on what is arguably another equally important dimension of the collision problem.

More in human factors

The Effects of Display Size on PerformanceSerendipity in Simulation: Building Environmentally Valid Driving Distraction Evaluations of Google Glass and an Android SmartphoneA Heuristic-Based Re-Evaluation of the IBM Academic Initiative Project InterfaceHysteresis in Mental Workload and Task Performance: The Influence of Demand Transitions and Task PrioritizationEffects of a Voice Interface on Mirror Check Decrements in Older and Younger Multitasking Drivers